Comparing quotes

Comparing heating and boiler quotes, line by line

Two quotes for what sounds like the same boiler can describe quite different jobs. This page and its checklist help you compare what each quote includes before you compare the totals.

Last reviewed · facts read at source on 3 November 2026 · published by SEO-DONS LTD · sources

The checklist

Build the list for your own job

Tick what your job involves and the checklist sets out the lines a written quote should show, the paperwork to expect and the rules that apply in England. It runs entirely in your browser and sends nothing anywhere.

1. What is being fitted?
2. Does the job also include…

Worked out in your browser. Nothing you tick is sent or stored. The rules shown are England's.

Lines the written quote should show

    Paperwork to expect afterwards

      Rules that apply

        Scope first

        Why the total is the last thing to compare

        A quote's total only means something once you know what it buys. One firm may include new thermostatic radiator valves, a magnetic filter, a carbon monoxide alarm and a chemical clean; another may price the boiler alone and leave the rest unsaid. The cheaper total may simply be the smaller job.

        So start with the scope. The Energy Saving Trust suggests getting at least three quotes; ask each firm to price the same job, then work down the lines below and mark anything a quote leaves out. A missing line is a prompt for a question, not proof of a cut corner. Still settling the job itself? New boiler installation covers a straightforward replacement and central heating installation a whole new system.

        The benchmark

        The one cost figure this site uses

        Prices move with the type of boiler, the pipework, any relocation, the flue and the condensate route, so this site publishes no price list or range. Its single benchmark is the Energy Saving Trust's £3,500 average for replacing a G-rated gas boiler with an A-rated model and thermostatic radiator valves, across Great Britain: one kind of job, with no range given.

        Treat it as a sense check for a simple swap, not a target. A quote well above it may cover more work, such as a change of type or new radiators. The boiler installation cost page explains what pushes a price up or down.

        Line by line

        What to compare on each quote

        Copy these rows into a notebook or spreadsheet with a column for each quote. The rules referred to are England's.

        Lines to compare across heating and boiler quotes, with the rule or advice behind each. Sources: Approved Documents L and J (England), Building Regulations 2010 regulation 20, Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 and the Energy Saving Trust; read 3 November 2026.
        LineWhat a complete quote saysWhy it matters
        The boilerMake, model and output in kWA new gas boiler in an existing home in England must reach at least 92% ErP
        How the size was reachedA heat loss calculation for the houseApproved Document L asks for one; from 24 March 2027 the old boiler’s output is not an appropriate basis
        ControlsEach control named and, for a combi, which of the four extra measuresRoom-by-room control, an interlock and separate timing (unless one controller does both) are expected when a boiler is replaced
        RadiatorsEach new radiator with its room, size and heat outputA new or fully replaced system is designed for a flow temperature of 55°C or lower
        Cleaning and inhibitorThe cleaning method, the inhibitor and any scale treatmentCircuits are cleaned and flushed, and an inhibitor added, before a new appliance goes in
        Magnetic filterA new filter, or the existing one checked and cleanedThe Energy Saving Trust says one should be fitted if there is none
        Flue and condensateWhere the flue ends outside and how the condensate pipe runsMinimum distances from openings, eaves, corners and boundaries apply
        Carbon monoxide alarmAn alarm in the boiler’s room, and its typeExpected with a new or replacement gas boiler in England
        Who does the gas workThe business’s Gas Safe Register numberGas and LPG boiler installers must be on the register
        PaperworkCompliance certificate, Benchmark checklist and manualsA copy of the certificate is due within 30 days of completion
        Price and paymentThe total with VAT shown, the deposit and any stage paymentsTotals only compare fairly when the scope is the same
        CancellingYour 14-day right to cancel if you sign at home or onlineWork should not start in that time unless you expressly ask

        When a line is missing

        Email the firm and ask for the missing item to be added and priced, or for a sentence explaining why your home does not need it. A reasoned "not needed" in writing is fine; a gap that nobody has explained is not something you can hold anyone to later.

        Sizing

        Sizing: the line that shows the most care

        Ask every firm how it arrived at the size of the boiler. England's Approved Document L asks for heating to be specified from an appropriate heat loss calculation and not significantly oversized, and for a gas combi to be able to turn down to the home's typical heating load.

        From 24 March 2027, when the 2026 edition applies, the guidance says outright that when only the boiler changes, a whole-dwelling heat loss calculation is appropriate and sizing from the old boiler's output is not. A quote that simply matches the old boiler deserves a follow-up question today. The boiler types page makes the same point for each kind of boiler.

        Water and commissioning

        Cleaning, inhibitor and the commissioning record

        England's guidance expects the circuits to be thoroughly cleaned and flushed before a new heating appliance goes in, a suitable inhibitor added, scale treatment for a combi's hot water in hard water areas, and commissioning to BS 7593, with the Benchmark checklist as one way to show it was done. Ask for that checklist to be completed and handed over.

        The quote should say how the cleaning will be done, and the choice of method is the installer's to explain. System cleaning and water treatment covers the methods and the filter.

        Safety

        The flue position and the CO alarm

        Where the flue ends outside is not a matter of taste. England's Approved Document J sets minimum distances for a fanned-draught balanced flue terminal, including 300 mm from an opening window or air vent, 600 mm from a facing surface or boundary and 300 mm above the ground. A quote that moves the boiler or flue should show the new route.

        The same document expects a carbon monoxide alarm in the room where a new or replacement gas boiler goes: one meeting BS EN 50291-1:2018, with a battery built to last its working life or fixed mains wiring rather than a plug, placed 1 m to 3 m from the boiler, measured horizontally. Flues, condensate and CO alarms has the full list.

        Paperwork and your rights

        Paperwork, and the right to change your mind

        Under regulation 20 of the Building Regulations 2010, an installer who self-certifies the work gives you a copy of the compliance certificate, and notifies building control, not more than 30 days after it is finished. The certificate is evidence of compliance, though not conclusive evidence. File it with the boiler manual, as the Energy Saving Trust suggests keeping these papers ready for when you sell.

        Sign at home or online and the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 normally give you 14 days to cancel a service contract. Work should not start in that time unless you expressly ask, in writing or another durable form if you signed at home. Cancel after asking for that early start and the charge is a proportionate amount, or nothing at all if nobody told you about the right to cancel. Contracts and cancelling covers the exceptions.

        Next steps

        When the quotes are in

        1. Run the checklist above for your job and note the list it gives you.
        2. Mark each quote against that list, line by line, and write down what is missing.
        3. Email each firm with its missing lines and ask for written answers.
        4. Check each business on the Gas Safe Register before you sign anything.
        5. Only then compare the totals, for the same scope and with VAT shown.

        Still deciding what to have fitted? The choice of boiler type and of heating controls shapes what a quote includes, and boiler or heat pump covers the bigger decision. If you would like one more quote to compare, get a heating quote.

        Questions about comparing quotes

        Is it worth getting three quotes for a new boiler?

        Yes. The Energy Saving Trust advises getting at least three, and three written quotes that each list their lines show you quickly what is normal for your job and what is an extra. Describe the job the same way to each firm, so their prices cover the same work.

        One quote is far cheaper than the others. What should I check first?

        Check what it leaves out, line by line: controls, cleaning and inhibitor, filter, carbon monoxide alarm, flue route and paperwork. If all of those are there and the business is on the Gas Safe Register, a lower price can be genuine; if lines are missing, ask for them to be added and priced.

        What if two quotes name different boilers?

        Compare what each boiler is being asked to do rather than the brand. Check that both meet the 92% ErP floor for a new gas boiler in an existing home in England, that each was sized from a heat loss calculation and, for a combi, which of the four extra measures comes with it. This site does not rank brands.

        A firm has sent a single total with no breakdown. What should I do?

        Ask for the lines behind it. Send the firm the list from the checklist on this page and ask it to confirm in writing which items the total includes and which it does not. Until it does, that quote cannot be compared fairly with the others.

        Does the checklist tell me whether a quote meets the rules?

        No. It works out, in your browser, which lines a quote for your kind of job should show, the paperwork to expect and which of England’s rules apply. It cannot read your quote or judge the work, so compare each quote against its list and ask the firm about anything missing.

        Where this page's facts come from

        Get a heating quote to set beside the others

        If you already hold a quote, tell us what it includes and what it costs, along with the boiler you have now and what you would like fitted. We reply by email.

        What happens next

        1. Your details go to SEO-DONS LTD, the company behind Heating and Boiler Installation.
        2. We read what you have sent about the house and its heating, and reply by email.
        3. Asking for a quote costs nothing and leaves you free to say no.
        Add more about the house and its heating (optional)

        Published by SEO Dons Ltd. We don't install boilers ourselves. We reply by email. See our privacy notice.

        Get a heating quote
        Get a heating quote