The choice
Boiler or heat pump? Cost, VAT, grants and running costs
When a gas boiler reaches the end of its life, a heat pump is the main alternative to weigh up. This page sets the two side by side on grants, VAT, running costs and who may fit them, and leaves the decision with you.
Last reviewed · facts read at source on 3 November 2026 · published by SEO-DONS LTD · sources
Grants
What the Boiler Upgrade Scheme pays towards
The name trips people up. GOV.UK describes the scheme as help with the cost of replacing fossil fuel heating with a heat pump or a biomass boiler, in England and Wales only. A gas boiler gets nothing from it, and nor does a hybrid system that combines a gas boiler with an air source heat pump. You do not claim the money yourself: an MCS certified installer applies, and the grant is taken off the quote.
Where fossil fuel heating is being replaced in England or Wales and the installer is MCS certified, the scheme lists £7,500 for an air source or ground source heat pump, £5,000 for a biomass boiler and £2,500 for an air-to-air heat pump. There is one grant per property.
One addition lasts until March 2027: if oil or LPG heats the home and there is no mains gas connection, the scheme adds £1,500 for an air or ground source heat pump, making £9,000 in total.
VAT
How VAT falls on each
Under HMRC's Notice 708/6, energy-efficient boilers are standard-rated at 20% unless the installation is grant-funded for a qualifying person; that narrow 5% case is explained on boiler installation cost. The notice's own examples show the contrast: a central heating system with a conventional boiler is one standard-rated supply, while the same system with an air, ground or water source heat pump is one zero-rated supply.
The zero rate for heat pumps installed in homes lasts until 31 March 2027. Budget 2026, published on 28 October 2026, confirmed that it reverts to the reduced rate of 5% from 1 April 2027, as planned. If a heat pump is on your list, ask each installer which rate their quote assumes.
Side by side
A new gas boiler and a heat pump compared
| What to weigh | New gas boiler | Heat pump |
|---|---|---|
| Grant | None. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme does not fund gas boilers or gas hybrids. | £7,500 towards an air source or ground source model in England and Wales, when it replaces fossil fuel heating and an MCS certified installer applies. |
| VAT on installation | 20%, or 5% only on grant-funded work ordered by a qualifying person. | 0% in homes until 31 March 2027, then 5% from 1 April 2027. |
| Who may fit it | An engineer from a business on the Gas Safe Register. | An MCS certified installer, for the grant. Gas Safe registration covers gas work, not heat pumps. |
| Energy price at the cap | Gas 7.97p per kWh, plus a 29.68p daily standing charge (including 5% VAT). | Electricity 26.32p per kWh, plus a 54.83p daily standing charge (no VAT). |
| Hot water | A combi heats water as it is used; system and regular boilers store it in a cylinder. | Most heat pumps are paired with a hot water cylinder. |
| Published cost benchmark | £3,500: the Energy Saving Trust’s GB average for replacing a G-rated gas boiler with an A-rated one, with thermostatic radiator valves. | None that this site can cite. Compare written quotes. |
Two registers for two different jobs
For a gas boiler, check that the engineer's business is on the Gas Safe Register and that boilers appear among the work categories on the back of the ID card. The register covers natural gas and LPG work, so it tells you nothing about heat pump skills; for a heat pump and its grant, the installer must be MCS certified. If one firm quotes for both, check it against each in turn.
Running costs
Illustrative example: cost per kWh of heat at the October to December 2026 price cap
A fair running-cost comparison divides the price of each fuel by how efficiently the system turns it into heat. The example below does exactly that with the figures stated, and it is valid only until 31 December 2026.
| System | Unit price used | Assumed efficiency | Cost per kWh of heat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Old gas boiler | Gas, 7.97p per kWh | 70% | About 11.4p |
| New condensing gas boiler | Gas, 7.97p per kWh | 90% | About 8.9p |
| Heat pump | Electricity, 26.32p per kWh | Seasonal performance of 3.0 | About 8.8p |
The assumptions behind the example
Ofgem cap 1 October to 31 December 2026, GB average Direct Debit: gas 7.97p per kWh, electricity 26.32p per kWh. Assumed efficiencies: new condensing boiler 90%, old boiler 70%, heat pump seasonal performance 3.0. Standing charges excluded. Valid only until 31 December 2026.
Electricity carries no VAT from 1 October 2026 to 1 July 2027, which flatters the heat pump figure in that window. Budget 2026 extended that zero rate to 1 July 2027 (before October it was 5%), although Ofgem's price cap page still gives the end date as 31 March 2027.
Read the result for what it is. On these assumptions the new boiler and the heat pump come out within about a tenth of a penny of each other per kWh of heat, and both well below the old boiler. Change an input, such as a lower seasonal performance, a different tariff or the next cap period, and the order can change, so the gap between rows is not a saving unless your own figures match these.
The policy
Do the rules force a switch?
Nothing published requires one in an existing home. The government's Warm Homes Plan, published in January 2026 and corrected in March, gives no end date for installing gas boilers in homes that already exist. It aims for more than 450,000 heat pumps to be fitted each year by 2030, expects heat pumps increasingly to become the natural choice for households replacing heating at the end of its life, and leaves low-carbon heating in new homes to the Future Homes and Buildings Standards.
The Clean Heat Market Mechanism is a separate matter, and it falls on the companies that make boilers rather than on you. Under it, manufacturers track and report how many fossil fuel boilers they sell in each scheme year, running April to March, from 2025 to 2028. GOV.UK's guidance is written for them and asks nothing of householders. There is more on the policy picture in can you still fit a gas boiler?
Your house
Questions only your house can answer
- Hot water. Most heat pumps run alongside a hot water cylinder, according to the Energy Saving Trust, so switching to a combi now may mean fitting a cylinder again if you move to a heat pump later. See hot water cylinders.
- Radiators. In England, a newly installed or fully replaced wet system should work at a flow temperature of 55°C at most, or the lowest design temperature that is feasible. Heat pumps are designed to run at low flow temperatures, so a system built this way keeps the option open; radiators and flow temperature explains the rule.
- Sizing. Approved Document L (England) expects any heat source to be sized using a heat loss calculation, without significant oversizing, so both quotes should show one.
- The boiler you have now. A combi, a system boiler and a regular boiler each set up the choice differently; combi, system or regular explains how.
Next step
Pricing both on equal terms
If you are undecided, price both properly rather than setting a heat pump quote against a bare boiler price. The Energy Saving Trust's advice to get at least three quotes applies to each. The boiler quote should include the controls, the system cleaning and the carbon monoxide alarm that a replacement in England brings with it, as described under new boiler installation; the heat pump quote should show the grant deducted and any work on radiators or a cylinder. Comparing heating quotes shows how to line them up, and you can get a heating quote through this site.
Questions about choosing a boiler or a heat pump
Does a hybrid of a gas boiler and a heat pump get the grant?
No. GOV.UK says you cannot get a Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant for a hybrid heat pump system, for example one that pairs a gas boiler with an air source heat pump. The grant only applies when fossil fuel heating is replaced by a heat pump or a biomass boiler.
How can I compare running costs for my own house?
Divide the unit price of each fuel by the efficiency of the system that uses it, then remember the standing charges. The illustrative example on this page does the first step at the October to December 2026 price cap, with its assumptions shown, and it is valid only until 31 December 2026. Your tariff, your house and how well each system is set up will change the answer.
Does the VAT on electricity change the running-cost sums?
For now, yes. Household electricity carries no VAT from 1 October 2026 to 1 July 2027, the end date Budget 2026 set (Ofgem’s cap page still gives 31 March 2027), which flatters heat pump running costs in that window. Gas under the cap includes 5% VAT.
Can a Gas Safe registered engineer fit my heat pump?
Gas Safe registration is about work on natural gas and LPG, so it does not show heat pump competence. For a Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant, the heat pump must be fitted by an MCS certified installer, who also makes the application.
Could I get the higher grant for an oil or LPG home?
Only in a narrow case. Until March 2027, the Boiler Upgrade Scheme adds £1,500 to its £7,500 grant for an air source or ground source heat pump for a home heated by oil or LPG with no connection to mains gas, making £9,000. The usual conditions still apply: a property in England or Wales, fossil fuel heating being replaced, and an MCS certified installer.
Where this page's facts come from
- GOV.UK — Boiler Upgrade Scheme: apply read 3 November 2026
- GOV.UK — Boiler Upgrade Scheme: what you can get read 3 November 2026
- HMRC — VAT Notice 708/6: energy-saving materials and heating equipment read 3 November 2026
- GOV.UK — Budget 2026 read 3 November 2026
- Ofgem — energy price cap unit rates and standing charges read 3 November 2026
- Energy Saving Trust — boilers (secondary source) read 3 November 2026
- GOV.UK — Warm Homes Plan (January 2026, corrected March 2026), PDF read 3 November 2026
- GOV.UK — Clean Heat Market Mechanism: boiler sales targets and credits read 3 November 2026
- HSE — the Gas Safe Register and the engineer ID card read 3 November 2026
- GOV.UK — Approved Document L, Volume 1: dwellings, 2021 edition incorporating 2023 amendments (PDF) read 3 November 2026
- GOV.UK — Approved Document J, 2022 amendments (PDF) read 3 November 2026
Weighing a boiler against a heat pump?
Tell us what heats the home now, whether it has mains gas and a hot water cylinder, and which option you would like priced. We reply by email.
What happens next
- Your details go to SEO-DONS LTD, the company behind Heating and Boiler Installation.
- We read what you have sent about the house and its heating, and reply by email.
- Asking for a quote costs nothing and leaves you free to say no.